The first file on the library hour ledger began with room hours, request slips and staff handoff notes. The city then checked the source, heard affected residents and sent a second office to repeat the count.

The current Year third, late winter window 2 file records 56 requests filled during the hours printed on the door; the previous window records 59. The longer sequence makes the change visible, while each count remains tied to its own dates.

A turning point was the observation that the staff handoff overlaps the only quiet hour for readers on the late schedule. It narrowed the discussion from a general claim to a question about how the rule works at the site.

The calendar counts the room as open. Readers say a room without a staffed request desk is not full access. The shared record is larger than it was at the start, although the parties still assign it different weight.

Asecond office compares arrival, service and publication times. The Year third, late winter window 2 file remains open for its scheduled decision. The library will record room hours and staffed request hours separately.